Science Minister Michelle Donelan has made a public apology and agreed to pay damages to academics Prof. Kate Sang and Dr. Kamna Patel after inaccurately accusing them of extremist sympathies, prompting discussions on academic freedom and governmental oversight.
UK Science Minister Michelle Donelan has issued an apology and agreed to pay undisclosed damages after retracting accusations of extremism against Prof. Kate Sang and Dr. Kamna Patel, academics associated with an equality and diversity advisory group within Research England, part of UK Research and Innovation (UKRI). The dispute began when Donelan wrongly alleged that Prof. Sang expressed sympathy for Hamas based on her social media activity, leading to the academics’ suspension pending investigation.
Following a comprehensive review, UKRI found no evidence supporting the claims of extremist views or support for Hamas. The investigation, prompted by accusations fueled by a report from the think tank Policy Exchange, concluded that the advisors had not violated any principles of public conduct. As a result of these findings, Donelan withdrew her earlier statements and publicly apologized, recognizing her misjudgment.
Prof. Sang voiced her intention to donate a portion of the damages to charity, expressing disappointment over the ordeal and the initial lack of direct communication that could have potentially clarified the misunderstanding. Dr. Patel and Prof. Sang both described the experience as distressing, especially considering their professional focus on promoting equality, diversity, and inclusion in the academic sector.
Additionally, the law firm Bindmans, representing Prof. Sang, criticized Policy Exchange for its misleading release that triggered the unfounded allegations. The firm highlighted the Science Minister’s lack of due diligence prior to making such serious accusations.
This occurrence has stirred debates on the boundaries of academic freedom and the governmental interference in scientific research and advisory roles. The retraction and apology from Minister Michelle Donelan have calmed immediate tensions but have raised broader concerns about the credibility and responsibilities of public officials in their oversight of academic and scientific work.
